Welcome to Russ McBee Sign in | Join | Help

The topsy-turvy state of human rights

Throughout the Cold War, propagandists in this country consistently painted the US as the world's champion of human rights and the rule of law, while the Soviet Union and its member states were cast as paragons of evil. Although neither characterization was entirely accurate, the relative comparison between the two did highlight stark differences between the freedom of the West and the oppression of the Soviet sphere.

Things have reversed almost exactly 180 degrees during the Bush presidency.

Today marks the sixth anniversary of the establishment of the American gulag at Guantanamo Bay; this dark stain on the character and history of our country continues to make a mockery of the notion that the United States still stands for human rights or the rule of law. The Bush White House has systematically destroyed nearly all remaining vestiges of America's former claim to any kind of moral superiority in the world, and I cannot foresee any way in which our previous stature among the nations of the world can be restored. This administration continues to break national and international law by holding captives outside both civilian law and the constraints of the Geneva Conventions; our outlaw president has done critical and irreparable damage to the notion that this country respects the rule of law for anyone except the moneyed and the privileged.

We should observe the Guantanamo anniversary by reflecting on how we have allowed this country's founding principles to be bastardized with perverse, malignant impunity.

Meanwhile, the former Soviet republic of Uzbekistan (which is not exactly a shining exemplar of human rights) has abolished the death penalty.

Today, a mere sixteen years after the Soviet Union collapsed, the US is the country building gulags, and the former Soviet republics are abolishing the death penalty because it's barbaric. Chew on that.

Share this post: Email | del.icio.us | Digg | Reddit
Published Friday, January 11, 2008 9:55 PM by RussMcBee

Comments

Friday, January 11, 2008 9:00 PM by cathymccaughan

# re: The topsy-turvy state of human rights

My mother and a friend in Guantanamo, 1949ish

My brother and his wife lived in Uzbekistan for 2 years. Several hours a day with no power. Mafia. Food and clothing shortages. Alcoholism. Give Uzbekistan about 50 years to get where we are now. Of course, by then we'll be something completely different.

Friday, January 11, 2008 9:16 PM by RussMcBee

# re: The topsy-turvy state of human rights

Thanks for posting the photo, Cathy. That's pretty amazing. I bet there's a fascinating story behind your Mom living at Guantanamo.

I really don't want to think about what the US will be in 50 years, but don't you find it ironic that a country as troubled as Uzbekistan can nevertheless join 134 other nations in abolishing the death penalty?

(I had to fix the HTML in your comment, since Community Server is very persnickity about HTML in comments.)

To prevent spam, anonymous comments are disabled. Click here to register for the site, or click here to sign in.